As demand for critical minerals continues to grow, mining companies face increasing pressure to bring new resources into production while navigating environmental requirements, operational risks and evolving stakeholder expectations.
During a recent Onterris webinar, Mark Breitfuss, Mining Sector Leader and David Isherwood, VP, Environment and Mining, shared their perspectives on the environmental considerations shaping mining projects across Canada, the United States and Australia.
The following Q&A highlights key insights from their discussion.
Q: How can the mining industry meet growing demand for critical minerals without compromising environmental stewardship?
Mark Breitfuss: The pressure to move projects from discovery to production as quickly as possible is increasing. However, the most effective way to accelerate approvals is through a deliberate, science-based approach and building trust between industry and regulators.
That means developing a strong technical foundation, engaging transparently with stakeholders and preparing comprehensive applications for regulators. It also means that industry needs to take a leadership role so that regulators can see the demonstrable improvements in data quality and risk assessments that underpin mining applications.
Trying to bypass these steps can lead to additional information requests and delays. Strong environmental planning is often one of the most effective schedule risk mitigation tools available. Projects that establish baseline environmental data early and identify permitting risks before applications are submitted are generally better positioned to maintain development timelines.
Proactive engagement with regulators and communities is equally important. Understanding expectations early can help address potential challenges before they affect the project schedule and builds on the foundations needed to establish and maintain social licence.
There is an ongoing challenge for industry and regulators to better share risk. This could be achieved through implementation of outcome-focused criteria for approvals rather than relying on outdated, prescriptive conditioning. Industry has the means to apply current practices and technologies, so is better positioned to meet regulatory requirements if the “guardrails” are known. Outcome-focused criteria support innovation and keep the risk management aspect with industry. Regulators can then set the expectation, but provide certainty to industry around both timeframes and assessment levels.
Q: Could reopening legacy mines help bring critical mineral supplies online more quickly?
David Isherwood: Legacy mines can offer advantages over greenfield developments. Existing infrastructure, known geology and historical operating data may shorten certain development and permitting timelines.
However, permitting may be faster without necessarily being easier. Operators must meet current environmental requirements, which may be significantly different from those in place when a mine originally operated. They also need to address historical environmental impacts and engage with Indigenous communities and other stakeholders.
Meaningful engagement with Indigenous communities should begin well before regulatory milestones. Early dialogue helps identify community priorities, potential concerns and opportunities for collaboration throughout the project lifecycle.
Modern expectations for water management, tailings storage, reclamation and emissions control all need to be considered. Beyond project-specific impacts, proponents increasingly need to understand cumulative environmental effects associated with regional development, including impacts to water resources, wildlife habitat and traditional land use. Addressing cumulative effects early can help reduce regulatory and stakeholder concerns later in the process.
Reopening a mine can be an important part of expanding critical mineral production, but the opportunity must be evaluated alongside the site’s environmental responsibilities.
Q: What are the most important water management considerations when planning a mining project?
Mark Breitfuss: Water is a finite resource, and competition for its use can be significant in many mining regions.
Early planning should establish how much water a project requires, where it will come from, how it will be stored and used, and what quality standards must be maintained.
It’s also important to consider how water may be managed or used beyond the mining operation itself.
Engaging with other water users and stakeholders helps operators understand competing demands and the broader importance of water within the region.
Taking these considerations into account early allows water management to become an integrated part of project planning rather than a challenge addressed later.
Q: How should mining companies account for environmental stewardship in capital and operating costs?
David Isherwood: Environmental stewardship should be built into the business case from day one.
Investments in water management, tailings facilities, emissions controls, monitoring systems and reclamation planning should be considered core project requirements rather than optional additions.
Companies also need to take a full life cycle approach to environmental costs. Monitoring, regulatory compliance, progressive reclamation and community engagement require ongoing investment throughout operations and into closure.
Strong environmental performance can help reduce long-term risks, avoid costly delays and manage future remediation liabilities.
The objective is to recognize environmental stewardship as a contributor to long-term asset value, rather than viewing it only as a cost.
Q: What makes community and stakeholder engagement effective during mine development?
Mark Breitfuss: Many critical mineral projects are being proposed in areas without a significant history of mining. This creates a different set of considerations for developers and surrounding communities.
Effective engagement begins with understanding who may be affected, what matters to them and how the proposed development could influence their communities.
An open, transparent and empathetic approach is essential, particularly when projects are being introduced in areas where mining activity is unfamiliar.
Building relationships takes time, but that investment can help establish the trust and understanding needed for a project to move forward.
Mining can also create economic opportunities for local communities, including opportunities for businesses and workers. Understanding these potential benefits alongside community concerns is an important part of the conversation.
Q: How can mining companies incorporate climate resilience into their projects and operations?
David Isherwood: Climate resilience needs to be considered from the beginning of project design.
Mining companies should evaluate potential exposure to extreme weather, flooding, drought, wildfires and changing temperatures, then determine how these risks could affect infrastructure and operations.
This includes protecting critical infrastructure, securing water availability, maintaining supply chain continuity and preparing for severe weather events.
Resilient infrastructure may require additional upfront capital investment, but it can help reduce the costs associated with disruptions, damage or rebuilding.
Mark Breitfuss: Climate adaptation is also becoming an increasingly important consideration in regulatory applications and closure planning.
Companies need to regularly review and update their systems, processes and risk management strategies as conditions change.
The goal is to improve operational certainty and reduce the likelihood of unexpected environmental events interrupting production.
Q: How can mining companies demonstrate their commitment to responsible mine closure and rehabilitation?
Mark Breitfuss: One of the most important principles is to follow through on the commitments made throughout a project’s life.
Rehabilitation should not be an afterthought, rather planning for closure will demonstrate intent. The best opportunities to undertake rehabilitation work may occur while operations are still active and equipment, personnel and infrastructure remain available.
Planning for closure early also allows operators to consider future land uses and engage communities in discussions about what the site could become.
Mining projects can operate for decades, so decisions made during development and operations can have implications for generations.
David Isherwood: Closure objectives also need to be supported by appropriate funding and operational planning.
Where practical, companies should begin implementing rehabilitation measures before production ends rather than leaving the full responsibility until closure.
Taking a long-term approach helps ensure environmental commitments can be carried through to completion.
Continue the conversation
Environmental expectations will continue to shape how mining projects are developed, operated and eventually closed.
Understanding these challenges throughout the mine life cycle can help organizations make more informed decisions and prepare for the opportunities ahead. Get in touch with our experts.