Who We Are
Onterris is a global environmental solutions company partnering with organizations to solve complex challenges where environmental pressures, regulatory expectations and operational risks intersect.
Sectors
Access deep environmental expertise tailored to your industry, with solutions built for real-world conditions.
Solutions
Prepare for escalating environmental risks with expert solutions designed to perform under pressure.
Our Thinking
Explore briefs, perspectives and articles that turn insight into action. Discover thought leadership that informs decisions and drives impact. See the ideas shaping environmental solutions and guiding your next move.
Cuture & Careers
Where brilliant people come together to turn environmental science into real-world progress for communities, industry and the planet.

EPA’s Coal Ash Proposal Creates a New Decision Point for Utilities

The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)’s proposed rule could give power generators more room to make site-specific closure decisions. The opportunity is real, but only for utilities that can support their position with clear data, sound judgment and a defensible record.

Aerial view of a coal ash storage and water management site supporting utility compliance and environmental decision-making.
Jacob Gruzalski
Jacob Gruzalski Jacob Gruzalski
Principal Geoscientist

Key takeaways

  • EPA’s proposal could move some coal ash decisions from fixed national requirements toward permit-based review
  • Utilities should identify where flexibility could change closure cost, schedule or remedy selection
  • The comment window is short: written comments are due June 12, 2026, with an online public hearing on May 28, 2026

What changed

On April 13, 2026, the EPA proposed amendments to the federal rules for coal combustion residuals (CCR), also known as coal ash. The proposal addresses legacy surface impoundments, dewatering structures, CCR management units, beneficial use and permitting flexibility.

The important shift is not just technical. EPA is signaling that some CCR decisions may be better made through permits that reflect site conditions, rather than one national framework applied the same way everywhere. EPA says the proposal would allow site-specific considerations in permitting, promote resource recovery, provide regulatory relief and continue protecting human health and the environment.

For utilities and independent power producers, that creates a practical question: which sites are good candidates for a more tailored strategy, and which are not?


Why it matters now

The proposal could affect closure plans, groundwater monitoring approaches, cleanup standards for some constituents and beneficial use timing. It may also matter most first in states with approved CCR permit programs, where permit-based decisions could move sooner than in other states.

This does not mean every site will benefit from flexibility. It means utilities need to know where flexibility could make a meaningful difference.

The best candidates are likely sites where a stronger record could support a different closure path, a different monitoring point or a more practical standard. The weaker candidates are sites where data gaps, unclear exposure pathways or unresolved groundwater questions make flexibility hard to defend.

That distinction matters. EPA is not replacing judgment with discretion. It is asking for decisions that can be explained, supported and reviewed.


What utilities should decide before June 12

Utilities should use the comment period to move from general awareness to portfolio-level decisions. The near-term priority is to separate sites that need attention now from sites that can wait.

Decision-makers should ask:

  • Which CCR units could see a material change in cost, schedule or closure approach
  • Which sites have enough information to support a permit-based argument
  • Where groundwater data or receptor information is incomplete
  • Which comment themes should be submitted before June 12
  • Whether the organization should participate in the May 28 public hearing

How state permit status affects timing and strategy

EPA is also asking for comment on whether similar flexibility should apply to some corrective action remedies. That is not yet a proposed requirement, but it is a signal worth watching. Utilities that prepare now will be better positioned if the final rule expands the role of risk-based decisions.


Next steps for power generation and utility operators

Start with a structured portfolio screen. Identify active, legacy and previously identified CCR units, then rank sites by regulatory urgency, permit pathway, data quality and potential business impact.

This step defines where flexibility is viable.

Focus effort where it will change the decision outcome. At priority sites, build a record that is clear, targeted and defensible. The objective is not more analysis, but alignment between data, risk and the proposed path.

A credible record should show:

  • What is known and supported by data
  • What drives site risk
  • Why the selected approach protects people and the environment

EPA’s proposal does not lower the bar. It increases the expectation that decisions are transparent, site-specific and technically sound.

Utilities that act now can shape both their comments and their permitting strategy. Those that wait risk tighter timelines and fewer options.

The window to act is short. The advantage will go to organizations that make clear, defensible choices.

Explore Related Content

Q&A: Environmental Challenges and Opportunities in Critical Minerals Development

From accelerating mine development to managing water resources and planning for closure, Onterris mining leaders answer key questions about the future of responsible mining

Why Pharma Manufacturers Need Treatment Strategies Built for Emerging Constituents

Future-ready wastewater treatment starts with knowing what’s in the stream, targeting priority constituents and building flexibility into the treatment train

Why Smarter Remediation Starts with Understanding Risk

Understanding actual site risks helps environmental professionals make smarter cleanup decisions, focus resources where they matter most and deliver lasting protection

Can You Trust the Environmental Data Behind Your Next Decision?

Eight questions for chemical and industrial environmental compliance leaders to pressure-test environmental data evidence before the next reporting, permitting or planning decision

What Makes an Effective Industrial Hygiene Program?

From identifying workplace hazards to verifying controls, a structured industrial hygiene program helps facilities prioritize risks and make informed safety decisions

From Data Centers to Global LNG Markets: The Growing Role of Certified Natural Gas

As buyers seek greater emissions transparency, verified methane performance is becoming a commercial consideration for natural gas suppliers and an increasingly important factor in the future of energy markets

Five Fundamentals of a World-Class Methane Management Program

Connecting defensible data, targeted measurement and operational practices to manage emissions and improve performance

California Proposition 45: Proposed Changes to CEQA Review for Qualifying Development Projects

The November ballot measure would amend the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) to establish a new pathway intended to expedite environmental review for qualifying projects, but key implementation questions remain

Turning Methane Data into Better Operational and Business Decisions

Using defensible methane data to prioritize action, improve performance and demonstrate value

How to Build a Measurement Strategy that Withstands Regulatory Evolution

A framework for chemical manufacturers to assess environmental monitoring technologies based on the decisions they support, risks they reduce and value they create