Who We Are
Onterris is a global environmental solutions company partnering with organizations to solve complex challenges where environmental pressures, regulatory expectations and operational risks intersect.
Sectors
Access deep environmental expertise tailored to your industry, with solutions built for real-world conditions.
Solutions
Prepare for escalating environmental risks with expert solutions designed to perform under pressure.
Our Thinking
Explore briefs, perspectives and articles that turn insight into action. Discover thought leadership that informs decisions and drives impact. See the ideas shaping environmental solutions and guiding your next move.
Cuture & Careers
Where brilliant people come together to turn environmental science into real-world progress for communities, industry and the planet.

Before You Buy a Brownfield: Keep the Bona Fide Prospective Purchaser Defense Intact

Environmental liability protection begins with thorough pre-acquisition due diligence, but preserving that protection requires buyers to actively manage environmental obligations after closing

Rusted industrial framework beside a river, with pilings, a warehouse, and trees in the background.
Derek Street
Derek Street Derek Street
Brownfields & Community Revitalization Practice

Key Takeaways

  • All Appropriate Inquiries (AAI) alone do not secure liability protection under the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation and Liability Act (CERCLA)
  • Buyers must satisfy ongoing “continuing obligations” to maintain the bona fide prospective purchaser (BFPP) defense
  • Missed follow-up investigations or unmanaged site conditions can expose owners to cleanup costs, financing challenges and lost redevelopment opportunities

Liability protection measures do not end at purchase

For organizations acquiring brownfields and other environmentally contaminated properties, liability protection is often a critical part of the business case. Many buyers understand the importance of conducting AAI through a Phase I Environmental Site Assessment (ESA) before acquisition to understand the site’s condition. Fewer recognize that this is only the first step.

The BFPP defense under CERCLA can protect purchasers from liability for pre-existing contamination, even when environmental conditions are known before acquisition. However, buyers must meet specific requirements to qualify and maintain that protection.

To qualify as a BFPP, buyers must meet the following threshold criteria before purchasing the property:

  • Acquire the property after January 11, 2002
  • Complete AAI before acquisition
  • Have no affiliation with a liable party
  • All disposal or release of hazardous substances must have occurred prior to acquisition
  • Comply with continuing obligations after acquisition

The final requirement is often where projects encounter risk.


Continuing obligations require ongoing attention

A Phase I ESA may identify recognized environmental conditions such as historical underground storage tanks, petroleum impacts or evidence of past industrial operations. These findings often require follow-up action.

Maintaining BFPP status requires property owners to:

  • Comply with land use restrictions and institutional controls
  • Avoid interfering with existing environmental remedies
  • Take reasonable steps to prevent or limit contaminant releases

Ignoring known environmental conditions can weaken or eliminate liability protections, regardless of who caused the contamination.


The business impact can be significant

Failure to meet BFPP requirements can affect more than legal liability. Developers, investors and property owners may face:

  • Increased exposure to cleanup costs
  • Delays or denials in project financing
  • Reduced eligibility for environmental grants and redevelopment funding
  • Greater scrutiny during future transactions

Organizations pursuing brownfields redevelopment projects should view environmental due diligence as an ongoing risk management strategy rather than a one-time transaction requirement.


Practical steps to protect BFPP status

Environmental liability protection is most effective when ownership of post-acquisition obligations is established before redevelopment planning begins.

After acquisition, continuing obligations become a core element of site governance and operational decision-making, not a legal afterthought. That means translating environmental findings and closing commitments into clear procedures that guide construction activities, property management practices and long-term site use. Assigning accountability early helps preserve liability protections, reduce compliance risks and prevent redevelopment decisions from undermining legal safeguards.

Consider these actions:

  • Assign ownership for continuing obligations across legal, environmental, construction and property management teams
  • Create a documentation process for inspections, notices, access requests and site condition changes
  • Confirm that institutional controls and land use restrictions are reflected in design, construction and tenant plans
  • Revisit the risk plan when new information, site work or redevelopment changes affect exposure pathways

The best-protected projects do not leave BFPP compliance in the closing file. They carry it into the decisions that shape redevelopment, operations and long-term site value.


Read the Before You Buy a Brownfield series

Purchasing and redeveloping brownfield properties can create value, but environmental liability protection depends on more than a strong site plan. This series explains how buyers, municipalities, Tribal nations, lenders and redevelopment partners can manage CERCLA risk through timely due diligence, disciplined documentation and strategic planning. The takeaway for decision-makers is clear: CERCLA risk management works best when liability protection is built into the project’s full life cycle, from acquisition planning through redevelopment.

Explore Related Content

Q&A: Environmental Challenges and Opportunities in Critical Minerals Development

From accelerating mine development to managing water resources and planning for closure, Onterris mining leaders answer key questions about the future of responsible mining

Australia’s EPBC Act Reforms: What Changes When Avoidance Comes First

The approvals playbook is changing, and early decisions matter more than ever

Why Smarter Remediation Starts with Understanding Risk

Understanding actual site risks helps environmental professionals make smarter cleanup decisions, focus resources where they matter most and deliver lasting protection

California Proposition 45: Proposed Changes to CEQA Review for Qualifying Development Projects

The November ballot measure would amend the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) to establish a new pathway intended to expedite environmental review for qualifying projects, but key implementation questions remain

California El Niño: Regulatory Guidance for Emergency Stream and Channel Work

Prepare for California El Niño impacts with guidance on emergency stream and channel work, regulatory coordination, documentation and response planning.

Rebuilding Highway 8 for a Changing River

See how Onterris helped rebuild Highway 8 along the Nicola River with climate-resilient bridge design, hydrotechnical engineering and habitat enhancements.

CERCLA Liability Exemptions for Brownfield Buyers

Learn which CERCLA liability exemptions and defenses may apply to brownfield owners, and why due diligence, AAI and documentation still matter.

Ontario O. Reg. 406/19: 2027 Excess Soil Rules

Ontario’s excess soil landfill restriction takes effect Jan. 1, 2027. Learn how O. Reg. 406/19 affects reuse planning, QP support and project schedules.

Building Environmental Certainty Before Shovels Hit the Ground

Early environmental insight helps project teams manage compliance risk, use resources more efficiently and build greater cost and schedule certainty into project delivery

How Ambient Air Monitoring Provides Context and Transparency for Data Centers

Ambient air monitoring helps data center developers establish pre-construction air quality baselines, track changing conditions and contribute to greater environmental transparency throughout the project lifecycle